The Oakland A’s dealt All-Star third baseman Josh Donaldson to the Toronto Blue Jays Friday night, will not be able to resign ace Jon Lester, who was picked up at the 2014 trade deadline for Yoenis Cespedes, and are now rumored to be talking to the Atlanta Braves about outfielder Justin Upton and catcher/outfielder Evan Gattis.
According to John Hickey of the Bay Area News Group, the price would be a high one. Starting pitcher Jeff Samardzija, who was picked up at the July trade deadline from the Chicago Cubs for a package that included starting pitcher Dan Straily and shortstop prospect Addison Russell.
Samardzija is under control for one more season before he reaches free agency. He earned over $5.3MM last season and will get a significant boost based on his performance between the Cubs and A’s in 2014.
Should he go to arbitration, Samardzija’s case will be further proof that a starting pitcher’s won-loss record is not very meaningful. Prior to being dealt to the A’s, the Notre Dame product was 2-7 despite a 2.83 ERA and 8.6 Ks per nine innings. As you would expect his ERA rose in the AL, but only to 3.14. He had an eight to one strikeout to walk ratio and a .262 BABIP or Batting Average on Balls in Play with the A’s and still finished just 5-6 in the W-L columns.
The Braves, who have already acquired starting pitcher Shelby Miller from the St. Louis Cardinals, would probably like to hold on to Upton, but can’t because of another player’s contract that is an albatross around their collective necks. Ironically, that contract belongs to Upton’s older brother B.J. Upton, who the Braves erroneously signed to a five-year, $75.25MM contract prior to the 2013 season.
The deal has been a disaster, with the 30-year old Upton posting OPS numbers you would expect from a pitcher – .557 and .620. Needless to say, the Braves can’t unload him.
The 27-year old Justin, on the other hand, has surpassed an .800 OPS in his two seasons in Atlanta and won a Silver Slugger Award last season after he hit 29 home runs and drove in a career high 102 runs.
The 28-year old Gattis hit 21 and 22 home runs in his first two seasons in the bigs, despite not reaching 400 at-bats in either year. Though he only caught and DH’ed this past season, Gattis played 48 games in the outfield in 2013. With just two years of Major League experience, Gattis is under the Braves control until 2019, which makes his inclusion in a deal (even for Samardzija) a head-scratcher.
While the team’s rotation would be bolstered by the addition of Samardzija – he would join Miller, Julio Teheran, Mike Minor, and Alex Wood – the Braves would be hurting for runs scored. It’s understandable that the Braves would rebuild their starting staff,pitchers Kris Medlen and Brandon Beachy are expected to miss the entire 2015 season after both underwent their second Tommy John surgeries this past Spring.
The acquisition of Miller cost the team outfielder Jason Heyward, which means Atlanta would be down three starters from their 2014 lineup, though perhaps someone like outfielder Josh Reddick could be sent along with Samardzija.
If the deal goes through, this is the Braves 2015 lineup at a glance:
Meanwhile the A’s starting rotation would be left with Sonny Gray and Scott Kazmir. Like the Braves rotation, the A’s had two pitchers – Jarrod Parker and A.J. Griffin – undergo Tommy John surgery this past Spring and can’t be counted on in 2015. Prospect Raul Alcantara, who has just two games of experience at Triple-A, could join the rotation some time during the season.